Bob Polaro interview
By Al Backiel
Q: Where did you receive your programming education?
Bob Polaro: In high school and college. Mostly using Basic, Cobol, Fortran and Assembly on mainframes.
Q: How did you land a job at Atari?
Bob Polaro: I had just left Commodore - programming the PET computer. Atari was just starting to develop on the Atari 800 and they were interested in me doing similar applications, games.
Q: What was it like at Atari? Was it laid back? Strict? Was there a dress code? Impossible deadlines? What did you guys do for amusement?
Bob Polaro: On my first interview I wore a blue vested suit. On my second they insisted I be more informal. Atari was very loose and friendly with a lot of cool people working there that liked to party, and play games, but also take great pride in the design process of video games. It was a lot like a college atmosphere. We were mostly the same age at that time (early to late twenties). More than just colleagues, we were friends. We had lots of space to develop, with large labs to work in as well as offices to escape to. We had no dress code. Most of us occasionally worked to the wee hours in the morning. We used to play volleyball out in the sand court a couple of days a week. Had a hot tub, sauna, and work out room, with frequent keg parties. Our building on Borregas in Sunnyvale was nicknamed the "Country Club". I remember when a half-dozen suits came into my lab to see my 2600 RealSports Volleyball game while I was wearing a tank top, shorts, and sandals. They would then inquire about a round ball.
Q: How long were you at Atari? Were you there when it was sold to Warner Bros.? Jack Tramiel?
Bob Polaro: I was there from 1978 to 1984. Best 6 years of my life. I was laid off shortly after Tramiel bought the company. They laid us all off, but then kept us on as contractors. I then quit shortly after.
Q: You did several programs while at Atari for their 800 computer. Mugwump sounds interesting. What was that one about?
Bob Polaro: The full name was Hide the Mugwump. Kind of like a cutesy Battleship-type game with kiddie animal characters.
(RIGHT): Stunt Cycle; (LEFT): Dukes of Hazzard version of Stunt Cycle
Q: Was Stunt Cycle based on the coin-op or that early dedicated video game console that came with the motorcycle handle bars?
Bob Polaro: Stunt Cycle was not only my first attempt at the 2600, but one of the first machine language programs I ever wrote. It was based on the dedicated Stunt Cycle console (Ed: Which was based on the arcade game of the same name). It was only 2K. The graphics were later changed to emulate the show Dukes of Hazzard using an orange car and a lake instead of the motorcycle and buses. The problem was the game used the paddle controller.
Q: How long did it take you to code and test Defender (2600)? How did you manage to do so much with so little storage?
Bob Polaro: About 6 months was the standard for most of these games. We were able to get away with such little ROM (4K) and RAM (128 bytes) because we didnít stress graphics as much as game play. The low-res playfield had a lot do with it as well. Most of the space was for logic. The drawbacks for the machine were the cycle limitations per scan line (called the 76 cycle blues) and only having 5 objects to move around: 2 missiles, 2 players, and a ball. If the calculations in the game loop exceeded a certain time the screen would roll, which was considered "fatal". Surprisingly enough however, we had lots of colors because all the lums were available.
Q: What are the steps to doing a coin-op translation like Defender? Do you get use of a coin-op to play? Do you get a copy of the original source code to look at? Do you work with video tapes or screen captures?
Bob Polaro: We had all the games in house that we translated to. The main challenge with Defender was getting it to work and feel right using only the joystick rather than all those buttons. A number of people actually preferred this version because of the ease of play. Hardcore gamers obviously like the coin-op version. The long range scanner was also quite tricky. The only thing I would have done different if I had to do it over again would be to make more of an effort to avoid the ship from disappearing when firing. The original source is usually useless to us because of the major design changes. Screen captures were also unnecessary. We just need the game play, then we add the graphics. Usually a whole game would be completed by just using boxes as the objects.
Q: Speaking of Road Runner for the 2600, why did it take Atari so long to release this game? The game is copyrighted 1989, but you left Atari in 1984.
Bob Polaro: Road Runner was my last 2600 game (and probably one of the last in the industry) and I donít know if the market was clearly defined at that time. I started it before being laid off, and then finished it as a contractor later, so I was separated from the inside scoop. It didnít take more than 6 months to develop so I guess it was on hold for a while.
Q: I noticed that you worked on several games which were stopped and put aside. Today Holey Moley, Dukes of Hazzard, Stunt Cycle and Bugs Bunny exist only as prototypes. Were you given other priorities? Did the licensing fall through? Did you find these decisions frustrating?
Bob Polaro: I always found it frustrating to put my heart and soul into a project and then have it shelved. I thought Bugs Bunny had the cutest graphics of any 2600 game. It had very simple but fun game play which would have been well suited for younger kids and uncoordinated adults. It play tested with teenagers against Snoopy & the Red Baron (which was a very unfair competition) some time in 1983. Bugs lost the competition, although it was more popular than Snoopy with the younger players. Bugs went back into development, where I added the second player option - both players playing at the same time, one as Bugs Bunny, and the other as Elmer Fudd. Elmer's hunting lodge was also added, as was the ability for Bugs to steal Elmer's bullets. This complete version of the game was readied for a Fall 1984 release by Atari but was shelved at the same time I was let go from Atari in early 1984.
Q: Holey Moley was a port of an obscure 1982 arcade game from Tai (http://flyers.arcade-museum.com/?page=flyer&db=videodb&id=510&image=1) that was reviewed in the March 1983 issue of Electronic Games (pg. 84). As far as we know, the only prototype that's been found was in your possession, dated 2-29-83, and according to him, the game was never really completed. One internal Atari document, dated 8-2-84, states this was completed with the comment, "Namco rip-off" (?). It's actually in MAME now, under its original name Mole Attack (here is a video of it). Did Atari actually have this coin-op for you to use?
Bob Polaro: Holey Moley was never really finished. It was meant for use with the Kid's Controller. We didn't have the coin-op game, but I may have referred to it at an arcade (Ed: The VCS prototype was released by Joe Cody of Atari2600.com and was first available at the CGE2K2 show, although he mistakenly used the CX number for Zoo Keeper).
Q: What of the game, Highway, for the 5200?
Bob Polaro: Highway was supposed to be an original driving game. Only a few weeks of work went into it. Alan Murphy (who did the graphics for Defender, R.S. Volleyball, Road Runner, Bugs Bunny, and Holey Moley) was doing the graphics for it.
Q: With the 2600 version of Rampage that you did for Activision, were you actually working there or was this done as a freelance assignment?
Bob Polaro: I did that on a contract basis for the newly-named Mediagenic. Just like all the other Rampage games they did, the debug stage took longer than anticipated due to the chaotic nature of the game.
Q: Regarding Easter eggs, by now most of our readers know how to find your hidden initials in Defender (LINK). What was the significance of the "25"?
Bob Polaro: If you caught a humanoid and hold him at exactly 25 lines above the city in the 25th wave the aliens would change to BPís as long as you held it there. I think most people would find this by accident by seeing the aliens flash as they passed that line.
Q: I was one of the first gamers to find your hidden initials in VCS Desert Falcon (Ed: Go for a swim around the northern part of the lake while carrying a super power, preferably invincibility - LINK), having reported it to Computer Entertainer newsletter back in March 1988. Are there any Easter eggs tucked away in Sprint Master, Road Runner, or any of your other 2600 games? If so, how does one access them?
Bob Polaro: RealSports Volleyball had a kind of Easter egg in that if you waited long enough, the screen would get darker and darker and a small shark would come out and go across the horizon (Ed: After loading, hit reset until you get to serve the ball. Red team/ left court. Then do nothing! Admire the sunset. When the sun has disappeared below the horizon, a shark fin can be seen crossing the horizon as darkness sets in. This takes about 8 minutes - LINK). Both mine and Alan Murphy's initials are in Bugs Bunny as well (LINK).
Q: I see from your list that you did several fishing games on various platforms for THQ. Are you a fisherman?
Bob Polaro: I took the job at THQ because I thought the idea of a fishing game on the SNES and Sega Genesis was a great refreshing change from the slew of fighting and side scrolling games. These were about bass fishing, but Iíve never caught a bass in my life! I didnít even know the names of any lures before I started that project. I do enjoy ocean fishing and have caught my share of large salmon.
Q: What was the status of BOBCO and the geography lessons? Was this your own corporation?
Bob Polaro: Some former Atari friends of mine started a small company developing educational software for the C-64 using a Kaypro 10 as a development environment. I decided to do the same thing while licensing some of their tools. I took a year developing World Geography which was similar in style to States and Capitals only on a "global" scale. I had the worldís best graphic artist, Alan Murphy, do the graphics for me on a royalty basis (he was the one that jokingly put BOBCO on the screen, which soon became the company name). I tried to get it published but found it was too "educational" for most game companies. Interestingly enough I approached Broderbund at the time but they were already working on a soon-to-be-very-popular geography game. They suggested to me to make the whole game multiple choice rather than a keyboard input-based game. I eventually published it myself and spent a year marketing it by going to shows and getting distribution. I had it available in German and Spanish, and licensed a version to AriolaSoft, a subsidiary of Bertlesmann in Europe. I sold a fair amount that way and even had it in catalogs opposite Broderbundís Product. I eventually wrote it for the Apple II, but was too late for the industry.
Q: On a more technical note, but in layman terms. What are the basic differences between coding in BASIC, 6502, 65816, and 68000?
Bob Polaro: BASIC is the high level language that most people first dabble with when starting to program. 6502 is the 8 bit assembly language used for the Atari, Commodore and Apple II computers. It consists of mostly loading and storing, using three letter commands such as LDA and STA. The 85816 was the 16 bit version of 6502 used in the SNES. The 68000 was used in the Sega Genesis.
Q: It looks like nowadays you are creating PC-based programs in C Language. How much different is this environment from the old days? Have you given any thoughts to doing something else for the older systems?
Bob Polaro: The main difference now is that Iím doing video redemption games which kind of go against the grain of my last 15 years of video game design. These games are designed solely based on arcade type earnings which means the game should only last a few minutes as you pump in quarters. The game play has to be as simple as possible. Iím used to games taking 40 hours to play in the homes. The advantage is it only takes about 2-3 months to finish a game and the debugging stage is fairly short due to the extremely simple and brief game playing time.
I think I might want to do a 2600 game again for old time sake.
Q: Who were some of your colleagues at Atari? Do you still maintain contact with them?
Bob Polaro: I pretty much had most of my friends there. We were all about the same age and single, so we hung out together for offsite after-work activities. I would say I currently stay in contact with about 20% of them. After all, most of us left Atari over 14 years ago!
Q: What memories do you have of your colleagues?
Bob Polaro: Hereís a short list (excuse my spelling):
Dennis Koble: His decision to have me work on the 2600.
Jim Huether, Warren Robinett: Showing me the ropes to the 2600.
Rob Fulop: A feature a day. The wisest of the bunch. A great, professional poker player.
Carla Meninski: The best of the few female designers. Dancing and singing in the labs.
Tod Frye: Climbing the walls!
Howard Scott Warshaw: Holding a styrofoam cup, flicking ashes into it while doing his shtick.
Alan Miller: The most mellow of them all.
Dave Johnson: Drank milk for his ulcer. Became one of my best friends.
Rick Mauer: The work of art of Space Invaders. The start of the new revolution.
Brad Stewart: His bad puns.
Marilyn Churchill: Did all the art for 8 games at a time.
Bill Aspromonte: Greatly upstaged Defender with Stargate. Great water-skier.
Sandy Maywald/Nick Turner: His fish tank.
Jim Andreasen: Lining up his cigarette butts. Always mellow and smiling.
Rob Zdybel: Biked to work on Matilda. A real Berkeley boy.
Eric Manghise: Great hats.
Andy Fuchs: His sound room.
Tom Reuterdaul: Great crepes (remember, Jim?).
Frank Hauseman: His Centipede game.
Doug Neubeur: Star Raiders was our favorite game. He was a chip designer.
Matt Hubbard: Winner on Jeopardy. Backgammon king. Lead singer in a punk band.
David Crane: Cranked them out.
Jan Boem: Running around carrying EPROMS.
Larry Kaplan: Air-Sea Battle. The best feel of any game.
Dan Hitchens: His "Berzerk" laugh.
Joe Copson: His vet pictures.
George Simcock: Going into Real Estate?
Mark Hahn: Called me a "beach weasel" and said "Life sucks, then you die!". He really wasnít a negative person, though.
These were the smartest, friendliest, funniest, and most diverse creative people Iíve ever known.
Flyer for Bob's "Baudacious Bob's Belated Beachview Bash!" Photo courtesy of Alan Murphy.
In January 2000, the USPS released its "Celebrate the Century: 1980s" series of commemorative stamps, and Bob's VCS Defender was chosen as the first video game to be depicted on a stamp. The public was polled on which game should be honored, and VCS Pac-Man was in the running to win, until someone noted it was based on a Japanese games and the series was meant to honor American contributions to the world. The VCS version was chosen over the original arcade version, since it would have been more difficult to depict the original's vector-like graphics.
To see more screenshots of Bob Polaro's games, check out his site at: http://www.polaro.com/screenshots/
Here's the Atari designers keynote from the 2007 and 2014 Classic Gaming Expos with Bob Polaro:
|various accounting packages||Data General Nova II||Adam Systems||released|
|Stock Portfolio||Commodore PET||Commodore||released|
|States and Capitals||Atari 400/800||Atari||released|
|European States and Capitals||Atari 400/800||Atari||released|
|Kingdom (aka Hammurabi)||Atari 400/800||Atari||released|
|Dice Poker||Atari 400/800||APX (Atari)||released|
|Hide The Mugwump||Atari 400/800||APX (Atari)||released|
|Lemonade Stand||Atari 400/800||APX (Atari)||released|
|Preschool Games||Atari 400/800||APX (Atari)||released|
|Reversi (Roman Checkers)||Atari 400/800||APX (Atari)||released|
|Space Trek (aka Atari Trek)||Atari 400/800||APX (Atari)||released|
|Stunt Cycle||Atari VCS/2600||Atari||unreleased|
|Dukes of Hazzard||Atari VCS/2600||Atari||unreleased|
|RealSports Volleyball||Atari VCS/2600||Atari||released|
|Bugs Bunny||Atari VCS/2600||Atari||unreleased|
|Holey Moley||Atari VCS/2600||Atari||not completed|
|Highway||Atari 5200||Atari||not completed|
|Rampage||Atari VCS/2600||Mediagenic (Activision)||released|
|Desert Falcon||Atari VCS/2600||Atari||released|
|Sprint Master||Atari VCS/2600||Atari||released|
|Road Runner||Atari VCS/2600||Atari||released|
|World Geography||C-64, Apple II||Bobco||released|
|World Geography (German)||C-64||AriolaSoft (Bertlesmann)||released|
|World Geography (Spanish)||C-64, Apple II||AriolaSoft (Bertlesmann)||released|
|Scuba Science||Apple II||Wings For Learning||released|
|"adventure game"||SNES||Illusions Gaming Co.|
|"strategy game"||SNES||Illusions Gaming Co.|
|Bass Masters Classic||SNES, PS||THQ||released|
|Bass Masters Classic (Japan)||SNES||THQ||released|
|Bass Masters Classic Pro Ed.||Genesis, SNES||THQ||released|
|Spider-Man 2 mini game||TV Plug-N-Play||Jakks||released|
|Slide Master||arcade/PC redemption||Lazertron||released|
|Hoppin' Harry||arcade/PC redemption||Lazertron||released|
|Word Master||arcade/PC redemption||Lazertron||released|
|Spin Streak||arcade/PC redemption||Lazertron||released|
|Solar Spin||arcade/PC redemption||Lazertron||released|
Return to main menu